Nothing reopens. On Wednesday 18 November, the national board said the 2018 ball-tampering case stays closed, with no fresh sanctions for anyone, even after Bancroft admitted he never gave a complete and honest account back then. In its place sits an independent forum that is confidential and voluntary, led by a former judge who has not yet been named. Whether anything it finds will ever be made public remains undecided, and the board has made no promise on that point yet, and the argument is still running.
Cricket Australia Sandpapergate Investigation Stays Closed
The board settled its position on Wednesday 18 November: the 2018 case will not be reopened. Greenberg called that earlier work completed, and the board confirmed that no new sanctions will follow for any player. Bancroft’s remarks landed the same day, and CA responded by saying it respects the decision to speak out and needs time to weigh what he said. Nothing more has been issued since, which leaves the formal stance unchanged, and for now the board is relying on the 2018 outcome and on the forum to carry any further discussion.
The 2018 findings limited advance knowledge of the plan to three men: Smith, Warner and Bancroft. Smith and Warner each received a 12-month ban, Bancroft was suspended for nine months, and Warner was also barred from any leadership role for life. In CA’s view, those penalties closed the matter, and a newspaper column years later does not change what the original inquiry concluded. That reasoning explains why the board is offering a discussion in place of a second hearing.
Independent Forum Takes Over
The forum is independent, confidential and voluntary, a design that favours candour over formality. A former judge or someone of similar standing will lead it, although CA has not said who. Terms of reference are still being finalised, and the board wants work to start as soon as it can, in a setting meant to make speaking up carry less risk than a public hearing would. Boon, the interim chair, announced the plan on 18 November.
Two questions remain open. The first is timing, and Greenberg hopes the process can wrap up in about a month. The second is openness, because CA has not committed to publishing what the forum learns. With participation voluntary, its value depends on whether people involved in 2018 choose to speak and whether the public ever gets to read the result.
Bancroft’s Column Shifts the Story
Bancroft used a newspaper column on 18 November to say the whole team was involved. He admitted that his version of events in 2018 was not full or truthful, and he said he kept back details such as the date sandpaper use started and the length of time it went on. The aim, by his account, was to protect CA’s investigation. That admission is the reason the board is facing questions again, because it means the 2018 inquiry itself worked from incomplete information.
His claim reaches well beyond the three men sanctioned. If the whole team was involved, the old finding that only Smith, Warner and Bancroft knew in advance looks incomplete. A confidential forum cannot easily correct a public record, and CA has so far answered with a process and no verdict. That gap between a closed file and an open admission is why the story keeps moving.
Cummins and the Captaincy Question
Pat Cummins’ side replied on 19 November through his manager, Neil Maxwell, who said Cummins’ position has not shifted in eight years. The response followed a Sydney press conference on 13 November, where Cummins dismissed Khawaja’s claim as nonsense. He rejected any idea that he knew sandpaper was being taken out and pointed to the bowlers’ 2021 denial. His camp is holding to a line it set long ago, and the latest statement adds nothing new to it.
Greenberg added on 19 November that the captain does not need to be cleared. Alongside the closed file and the new forum, that remark shows how CA wants the issue handled: contained, private and quick, with the focus kept on process. The Cricket Australia sandpapergate investigation is shut, and the forum is the only route left for anyone with more to say.
Stay updated on the latest cricket news and exciting updates at Six6slive. Dive into our in-depth articles and analyses to connect with the action today!