Australia left out their most experienced spinner for the innings defeat in Gqeberha, and the cost was plain: South Africa piled up 425 for 9 declared before Australia fell for 99 and 295. Lyon was the only change from the Durban side, which left four quicks and no frontline spinner to hold an end when the batters took control. With the final match starting October 27, the selectors face a call that Cummins has described as a delicate balance, and every option carries a cost.
A Heavy Defeat in Gqeberha
South Africa declared at 425 for 9 and then bowled Australia out for 99 in the first innings, leaving the visitors chasing the game from the opening day. Australia improved to 295 second time around but still lost by an innings and 31 runs. The side went in with four quicks and no frontline spinner, a plan that left the attack with one way to bowl and no variation once South Africa settled into a long stand. Boland took 5 for 81, while Renshaw’s five overs cost 18 runs without reward.
Cummins offered two readings of the match, and they pull in different directions. On toss day he said conditions played a part, and afterwards he admitted the team was a long way from its best. Those comments sit awkwardly together, because blaming the pitch is easier than explaining why a proven spinner sat out. No comment from McDonald on the selection, the attack or Lyon himself has surfaced.
Nathan Lyon omission World Test Championship decider
Cummins has called the changes a delicate balance, and the phrase fits the choice facing the selectors. Lyon is expected back if the surface at Newlands suits him, which would leave one of the seamers Boland, Hazlewood and Starc on the bench. Dropping a quick is the price of restoring the spinner, and that is the trade-off at the heart of the call, one that gets harder because all three seamers have claims on a place.
The squad of 16 gives them options beyond the veteran, which is a comfort and a complication at once. Left-armer Kuhnemann is in it, as are Connolly, who is back after not bowling since March, plus Renshaw and Webster. No news on Kuhnemann’s availability has emerged, so Lyon looks the safest pick if a specialist is wanted. Renshaw’s blank return in Gqeberha does little to argue the case for a part-time option, so the choice looks like Lyon or nobody.
The Veteran’s Career Record
Across 141 Tests, he has taken 567 wickets at 30.15, a record that carries weight in any selection room and puts him among the most productive spinners of his time. South Africa has been tougher territory. Against them he has 56 wickets at 40.80 from 19 Tests, and inside the country he has 28 wickets at 39.75 across 9 matches between 2011 and 2018.
Those South African averages are the argument against him, and they are not small figures to wave away. Yet the same country gave him a landmark, because his 300th Test wicket came at Newlands in March 2018. His record at that ground specifically is not available, but the history sits close to the selection debate. A spinner with that background earns a hearing even when the numbers are blunt, and the selectors know it.
Green, Inglis and the Fitness Picture
Green missed the first two matches with an abdominal strain, and Cummins expects both him and Inglis to be available for the final game. Green is a batter only if picked and is not expected to bowl, with doubts over his full workload. Inglis has recovered from a finger fracture and is fit again. Their return would deepen the batting after a first innings of 99, which will matter if the pitch asks hard questions of the top order.
Fitness will shape how many bowlers the side can carry. If Green plays purely as a batter, the bowling resources must come from elsewhere, and that is where the Nathan Lyon omission World Test Championship decider debate bites hardest: bring back the spinner and a quick falls out. The choice made before October 27 will say plenty about how Australia read the conditions and how much they trust their own plan.
Stay updated on the latest cricket news and exciting updates at Six6slive. Dive into our in-depth articles and analyses to connect with the action today!